Tiffany Maher & Kyle Spence

So You Think You Can Dance and Hit the Floor alum Tiffany Maher married entrepreneur Kyle Spence at the Bahia Mar resort by Hilton off the coast of Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, on Dec. 17 surrounded by 250 of their closest friends and family members.

The groom wore a traditional black tux from Indochino which matched Maher’s traditional wedding look that included an Elysee dress.

“It wasn’t the typical, you try on the first dress and say yes to the dress. I definitely went to a ton of stores,” she told PEOPLE. “I ended up getting it from this place in Miami. I wore my hair down, just so that when I look back, it’s me. I didn’t do anything for the first time that day.”